Work - Good for your health?

Work is good for your health, according to the Government in its recent consultation document on reforming the welfare state. Yet five million workers in Britain suffer from stress at work and half a million of them believe this makes them ill. A survey by the Samaritans found that people’s jobs were the single biggest cause of stress. According to the Government’s own research, mental health conditions are now the single biggest cause of absence from work and of claims for incapacity benefit.

The number of people claiming the benefit more than trebled between 1979 and 1997. This is also the period when the Conservative Government passed laws which greatly restricted and controlled trade union activity. Has this disenfranchisement of working people led to a situation where incapacity benefit provides the only respite for those for whom work has become unbearable?

My experience has led me to believe this is so. When I became ill as a result of workplace stress, my employer promptly made me redundant. My trade union proved to be as bureaucratic as it was toothless. I could not afford a lawyer and public funding is not available for employment tribunal cases. So I had to take on my employer single-handedly. Needless to say, the added stress did nothing to improve my stress levels.

Had I left my job before I became ill and signed on while looking for another one, I would have made myself “voluntarily unemployed” and thus being penalised with a “sanction” of up to 26 weeks without any money. So I had no choice but to stay put until my stress levels reached crisis point and I had to escape – first to my GP and then onto incapacity benefit.

I now live on £86 per week, out of which I have to pay for prescriptions, dental and osteopathic treatment. I get no help with travel expenses. Consequently, I am often forced to choose between lunch and a bus pass. I am continually subjected to “medical assessments” and “work-based interviews” by the local Jobcentre. I am stigmatised by the right-wing media.

So how is the Government planning to help me and others in my position? The consultation document tells me that the “Access to Work” budget is to be doubled to £140 million and that public and private sector “providers” will be paid out of benefit savings to get incapacity claimants back to work. In other words, money will be taken away from the sick and disabled and given to Government departments and private companies which care about targets and profits, not claimants. A further £173 million will be spent on “psychological therapies”, provided by therapists who are to work alongside Jobcentre advisors to “support” people to get off welfare benefits.

Here is my response to the consultation document: Stop kicking the victims of rampant capitalism. Stop telling us that being bullied off benefits is good for our health. Stop pouring money into machinery designed to deprive us further and leave us in peace, so that we can get better and/or find alternative ways to make a contribution to society.

Are you working the system?

A few points Carol.

You DID have a choice before going onto incapacity benefits… you could have got another job, perhaps one with less stress levels. You don’t state in your article what work you did and you automatically make an assumption that you would have had your money stopped when on JSA. This is not the case. You MAY lose your entitlements to JSA is you make yourself voluntarily unemployed but the rules allow for flexibility especially around “good cause”.

If your position was so untenable that you HAD to leave, any decision maker employed by DWP worth their salt would have looked upon that fairly favourable.

As it is now, I suspect that as you are getting £86 per week rather than a Jobseekers £60.50 and not getting help with prescriptions you have taken the very clever step of stating you are INCAPABLE of work a benefit based on your national insurance credits rather than income. This then gives you unlimited benefits regardless of income. As for not getting prescriptions free of charge may a suggest a move to Wales or in a few years time Scotland. May I also suggest you find work as a journalist or political activist as your article above clearly demonstrates ability in both?

The Diversionary State

Carola Becker – I am glad you did this story – this story will increase in its frequency of concerns shown over the next few years .. In Mental Health the Govt in 2002 – 4 started to architect a way forward that has actually led to more treatment-diversionary in-house Service User bureaucracy in Mental Health and social engineering bureaucracies like NIMHE – they’ve cost so far maybe 200 million …That is a lot of lost opportunity . Patient Choice of therapy and recovery help might well have helped people to obtain the help they needed but instead many have had across the UK crap psychologists with a poverty of empathy . I’ve monotored these services and they are shameful but will continue to perpetuate misery – not creativity and not individualised growth .

The benefit system too is crazy because it needs to support people and do so without being so threatening and punitive because frankly I know of many Service Users that cannot operate under threat. How can we get the best out of people under threat and a new fascism towards those of benefits re-inforced by a media that perpetuates over-generalised prejudicial perceptions …

Stay alive and as well as you can – Silvis Rivers .

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is used to make sure you are a human visitor and to prevent spam submissions.